*Notes: I refer to George Lucas basically creating the first six Star Wars films entirely by himself. Of course, this isn't true as hundreds of people, including other directors and writers, created the films. My main point is that he had total creative control over the series and could change anything he wanted.
Also, while I posit that it might be better if Lucas had not sold to Disney, overall, I am still optimistic about the future of Star Wars because, as a true fan, I think that more Star Wars is ultimately better than no Star Wars...for now.
“I think the fans are going to love it. It’s
very much the kind of movie they’ve been looking for.” This was George Lucas’s
response to The Force Awakens, and after seeing both that film and The
Last Jedi, two things have occurred to me in regards to that quote. One,
the new Star Wars films are essentially fan films, made by fans
attempting to give the fans what they want. And two, I wish Lucas had never
sold Star Wars to Disney.
That quote explains exactly why I have issues
with the new movies. They were made in an effort to give the fans what they
want. The problem is what fans want isn’t necessarily good for the film, not to
mention that Star Wars fans are notoriously divided about what they like
in the series. Most of all, fans are meant to wait for new material, not
dictate it. This is why George Lucas should have held onto Star Wars.
Like it or not, what he made was Star Wars. He told the stories he
wanted to tell how he wanted to tell them, and he did not seem to care about
fan feedback. Lucas didn’t create perfect films (he obviously agrees with this
since he had a habit of going back and altering the original films), but he
made the films he wanted to make.
It feels like Disney is just placating fans, and
plenty of people seem fine with it. But I’m disappointed. My biggest problem
(which is likely never to be fixed) is that these new films do not feel like Star
Wars films. Sure, they look and sound like Star Wars movies, but
something is missing. I cannot point to anything specific aside from the fact
that Lucas is not involved. Without Lucas, these are fan films, and fan films,
while at times impressive, are never as good as the real thing. That’s not
likely to change, and I’ll have to accept that. But part of me wishes Lucas had
never sold to Disney. Part of me wishes the series stopped for good after the
prequels. I can’t believe I even partially feel that way, but The Last Jedi has
really left me disappointed with this series. Star Wars was still sacred
to me before the new films, and now it’s quickly turning into just another
bloated franchise.
As I pointed out in my previous articles, I did
not think that The Last Jedi took Star Wars in a new direction. I
wish it had, but I saw far too many similarities to Empire and Return
of the Jedi to consider it a very original entry in the series. I don’t
blame writer/director Rian Johnson completely for this. It seems to me that he
was also disappointed with The Force Awakens, which is why he dismissed
so much of it while also speeding through the inevitable retreads of Empire and
Return of the Jedi. For doing this, Disney is giving him his own
trilogy, which I look forward to since he won’t be beholden to anyone but himself.
This situation is exactly what’s wrong with Disney’s approach to the series.
Lucas had total control over the series. Of
course, total control leads to a few issues. Lucas obviously didn’t do
everything by himself, but he was the final decision-maker, and he did not have
to answer to anyone. That led to Jar Jar Binks and some truly abysmal romantic
dialogue, but it also led to some amazing lightsaber action and a totally
fulfilling character arc for Obi-Wan Kenobi, among other things. It led to a
singular vision for the series. Disney threw that out the window when they
decided to hire different directors for each film, but there is hope.
Disney saw something in Rian Johnson, but it
seems like they also realized that he messed with the direction of the core
films. How else do you explain giving Johnson his own trilogy while also
handing Episode IX back to J. J. Abrams? It’s possible that they regret
not having Abrams write and direct the entire trilogy. At this point, I wish
they had. Sure, it’s likely that Abrams would have continued on the rehash path
he started, but at least it would have been consistent. Now that he’s back in
charge, we might see the mysteries and plots abandoned by Johnson revisited. If
that’s the case, then this is going to end up being a sloppy trilogy. (And
that’s how I will refer to it: there’s the original trilogy, the prequel
trilogy, and the sloppy trilogy.)
This is something you never had to worry about
with Lucas’s films. If a mystery was set up in the original trilogy, it was
explained. And everything you still had questions about was explained in the
prequels. The Lucas films may have their inconsistencies, but at least he never
set up a bunch of mysteries, and then handed off the next film to someone else.
Perhaps the biggest problem is that the story
wranglers at Disney obviously did not come up with a master plan for all these
writer/directors-for-hire. Lucas took six films to tell the complete story of
Darth Vader. Where do you go from there? How do these new films fit into that
aside from his children and his grandchild still being around? And if we are
moving on from Star Wars being about Skywalkers primarily, then what is
the overall story arc for the new trilogy? Does anyone even know?
My biggest concern is Disney. Lucas may have
been all about toys and allowing people to create new Star Wars books,
games, cartoons, etc. But it was all separate from the core movies. In other
words, you could ignore all the side stuff if you wanted, or you could take a
deep dive in the expanded universe for more Star Wars. How long before
Disney makes it seem like a requirement to play the games, read the books, and
watch the cartoons? This already happened on a minor scale with C-3P0’s stupid
red arm in Force Awakens. He mentions the arm, but it’s dismissed and
never explained...unless you read a comic book that explains it. It’s fine if
there are books and whatnot that fill in the blanks between Jedi and Force
Awakens, but to point out some stupid little detail in a movie in the hopes
of selling a few comic books is distracting, stupid, and troubling. It starts
with a red arm, but it might lead to an entire character’s fate being left to
some other media you have to buy. Lucas would create extra characters just to
make toys of them, sure, but it wasn’t as obvious and/or distracting as the red
arm.
The Last Jedi didn’t
introduce any red arm nonsense, but by abandoning so many mysteries, it did
leave the door open for major story details to be hashed out in other places.
Is there going to be a Snoke comic book origin? Will the Knights of Ren be
explained in a video game? If so, then fuck Disney. Also, fuck me for being
stupid enough to read that comic book and play that videogame. Lucas allowed
you to dork out if you wanted to; Disney might be making it a requirement.
Finally, Lucas being a one man show meant
something else: there were only so many movies he could make. Since he was
unwilling to let other people completely take over new films, he only made one
at a time. And he took his time. Each release was special and exciting. Now,
we’re looking at a yearly Star Wars movie forever. How long before this
turns into Marvel fatigue? Sure, Marvel is chugging along just fine, but
personally, I haven’t felt that need to watch the last four or five Marvel
movies in the theater because it’s all getting too familiar or convoluted. Can
I watch Thor: Ragnarok if I haven’t watched Doctor Strange? It
feels like homework. Is this going to happen to Star Wars? I sincerely
hope not. But one thing’s for sure, if George Lucas was still in charge, this
isn’t something I would have to worry about. There probably would never have
been another Star Wars movie if that was the case, but right now that
seems better. Too much of a good thing is can be bad. Too much of a mediocre
thing is much worse.
No comments:
Post a Comment