Showing posts with label Madden. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Madden. Show all posts

Friday, November 20, 2026

Madden - "The Heroin of Crackers."

When I saw the first images released for Madden (out now on Prime Video), David O. Russell’s biopic of John Madden, I thought it was a joke. And I was right. If you go into this film, which focuses on the end of Madden’s coaching career and his transition into broadcasting and videogames, thinking it’s going to be traditional or serious, then you might come away thinking it’s the worst movie of the year, if you can manage to finish it. I wouldn’t blame anyone for thinking that no matter how you approach this movie. Madden is a silly mess, but I somehow enjoyed it. Let me break it down for you, Madden-style (not really because I know very little about football strategy).

The first step is getting used to Nicolas Cage’s portrayal of Madden. He looks ridiculous in a fat suit and wig, and the voice is otherworldly. He never sounds like Madden, but I eventually got used to it. I love Cage, but he is simply miscast here. To be fair, Madden is a tough person to replicate. But Cage is just the wrong choice. Somehow it didn’t bother me enough to stop watching. 


The next hurdle is Russell’s filmmaking style. Ever since he found success with American Hustle, he’s been trying to be Martin Scorsese, and it just gets worse and worse. The cussing is overbearing at times, characters talk directly to the audience too often, the needle drops are uninspired, and the editing is simply awful. A simple scene in a kitchen features so many weird cuts that it becomes distracting and feels like it was filmed in different locations and timezones even though wide shots show all the actors were in the room together. Perhaps Russell’s work is mainly useful as an example of how great of an editor Thelma Schoonmaker is (she’s been a Scorsese mainstay for decades). 


The style of the film almost did me in, but Christian Bale as Al Davis saved the entire production. Bale is Russell’s ride-or-die ever since he won an Oscar in Russell’s much better film, The Fighter. Bale is one of those actors who is going to commit no matter how strong or weak the film is, and that’s certainly the case here. Every moment Bale is on the screen the film becomes exponentially more watchable. His back and forth with Cage is great. Their chaotic, meandering conversations are easily the highlight of the film. In a film about football, my favorite scene was Bale and Cage discussing their favorite crackers. And his portrayal of Davis doesn’t feel like a simple impression; he feels like a real character in a film filled with caricatures. He’ll receive no love from critics groups this year as this film is being summarily dismissed, but he should be in the conversation for Best Supporting Actor. I feel crazy typing that, but I truly feel like he saves the film. 


Beyond Bale, there are glimmers of something interesting here. The football scenes in general are quite weak, as it feels like we’re watching stock footage as the actors react in front of a green screen. But when it cuts to Madden, we’re in his head and start seeing the Xs and Os. If that had been more of the focus for each game, it could’ve been more interesting visually. 


Most importantly, Madden is a comedy, and an outrageous one at that. I’ve seen people comparing the film to an extended SNL skit or a Funny or Die video, and that’s a fair comparison. And since comedy is so subjective, it makes Madden easier to hate. If the sloppiness of the film is too distracting for you to find the humor in it, then this will be a failure. 


But if you’re like me, and you have a passing interest in the subject, and you’ve played any of the Madden games, then you might be able to stick with this long enough to find some fun with it. 


Random Thoughts


Nice of them to toss a couple jokes at Al Davis’s weird-looking son, Mark. 


Shane Gillis is just being Shane Gillis in this. If you hate him, then it will get on your nerves. If you’re like me, and you find him funny from time to time, you’ll think it’s fine. And if you’re one of his lunatic fans that thinks his very presence is hilarious, then you’ll think the only good parts of the film are his scenes. 


It was nice that they gave him a perm, because now we know Gillis is a dead-ringer for John Candy from Planes, Trains, & Automobiles.


The ‘70s era NFL stuff was great, with how casual these big games seemed to be back then. Not sure how accurate it is, but the game was definitely smaller back then. 


John Mulaney is fine in this.


It was amusing that they put Marshawn Lynch in the film not as a football player, but as one of the developers of the game.


It’s crazy that Sienna Miller is now relegated to just playing wives in films now. She has more of a role than you might think, but still feels like too small of a part.


Kathryn Hahn is going for it as Madden’s wife, Virginia.


As always with this kind of shit, I think I was okay with it because I was able to watch it at home. Had I paid money and made plans to go to the theater for this, then I probably wouldn’t have been so forgiving.